When We Advised Against Managed IT (And Why)
This is a situation we see more often than people expect.
A business reaches a point where IT feels heavier than it used to.
Issues aren’t constant, but they’re disruptive when they happen.
Leadership starts hearing phrases like “You probably need managed IT now.”
In this case, a local professional services firm had about a dozen staff, stable systems, and a small internal IT presence that handled day-to-day needs reasonably well.
Nothing was on fire.
But uncertainty was starting to creep in.
The Pressure They Felt
The leadership team felt pulled in two directions.
On one hand:
On the other hand:
They came to us expecting a recommendation to “move fully managed.”
What They Expected Us to Recommend
Based on how most conversations like this go, they assumed the answer would be:
“You’ve reached the size where managed IT makes sense. Let’s get you on a plan.”
That would have been an easy recommendation.
It also would have been premature.
What We Actually Advised
We advised against moving to full managed IT, at least for now.
Instead, we recommended a lighter, hybrid support model focused on:
No full monitoring stack.
No forced tooling changes.
No long-term commitment.
Just enough structure to reduce risk without adding unnecessary overhead.
The Tradeoff We Accepted
This wasn’t the highest-revenue option.
Managed IT would have generated more recurring revenue and locked in more responsibility on our side.
But it also would have:
We accepted the tradeoff of less immediate scope in favor of a better long-term fit.
Why This Reduced Risk Long-Term
Six months later, the outcome was exactly what we hoped for.
The environment was clearer.
Documentation existed and was usable.
Access ownership was defined.
Leadership felt more confident, not more dependent.
When growth and complexity eventually increased, the decision to move toward managed IT was calm, informed, and well-timed — not reactive.
Managed IT works best when it’s intentional, not defensive.
Sometimes the lowest-risk move is waiting until the structure actually needs to be carried.
Other Decision Guides:
✔️ When Managed IT Makes Sense
✔️ Do We Need Managed IT Yet? (tool)
✔️ A Healthcare Practice Under Compliance Pressure, What We Prioritized
✔️ Decision Guides hub